Trunk vs BuildPulse
Trunk’s Flaky Tests is a comprehensive platform designed to detect, analyze, and manage flaky tests within your CI/CD pipeline.
Tired of clicking re-run? They were too.
Features
Notifications (GitHub, Slack, Email, etc.)
Test Framework and CI Provider Agnostic
Test Quarantining
Auto Detection
Comprehensive Dashboard
Integrated Ticketing
Detailed Failure Analysis
"Trunk's Flaky Test solution is so far the best one we've worked with, and we look forward to continuing to work with it."
"I primarily focused on the flaky tests tab and found all the information I sought. The app provided an excellent summary of our E2E pain points."
Security Overview
Your code is your IP, that’s why security and privacy are core to our design. We minimize data collection, storage, and access whenever possible. We operate using the principle of least privilege at all levels of our product and processes.
FAQs
What are Trunk Flaky Tests?
Trunk Flaky Tests is a tool designed to tackle the nuisance of flaky tests with an integrated approach. It identifies flaky tests and provides deep analytics to understand test health and root causes—essentially offering a 360-degree view of your test suite. With seamless integration into platforms like GitHub and Jira, it automates tasks that otherwise eat up valuable development time. It's like giving your development process a productivity boost, especially for large teams that need more than just flaky test detection.
What is the primary focus of BuildPulse?
BuildPulse zeros in on flaky test detection and reporting, providing detailed analysis to help teams manage test reliability. It's a straightforward tool to reduce CI costs by flagging flaky tests and offering insights into their occurrence. For small to mid-sized teams that want to get to the crux of test flakiness without extra bells and whistles, BuildPulse is a no-nonsense choice.
How does Trunk Flaky Tests automate developer workflows?
Trunk Flaky Tests automates many developer tasks through its integration capabilities. With features like GitHub pull request comments, Jira tickets, and webhooks, it reduces the developer's busywork. Imagine fewer manual updates and more integration with your daily tools; it makes for a smoother, less stressful workflow. This means developers can focus more on coding and less on menial tasks.
How does BuildPulse detect flaky tests?
BuildPulse utilizes an automatic detection mechanism to pinpoint flaky tests by analyzing test result patterns. It looks for inconsistent pass/fail reports that signal instability, helping to isolate and address the core issues within the test suite. Think of it as having vigilant eyes on your tests, ensuring they perform as expected consistently.
What makes Trunk's analytics engine stand out?
Trunk's robust analytics engine offers flaky test detection and a holistic overview of your test environment. It identifies trends and prioritizes fixes by providing detailed insights, enabling developers to concentrate on high-impact areas. This comprehensive level of analysis sets it apart from tools that focus solely on basic reporting.
Can BuildPulse reduce CI costs?
By focusing on flaky test detection and advocating test stability, BuildPulse can indeed help reduce CI costs. When tests are reliable, resources are spent more effectively, and less time is wasted rerunning tests or fixing unidentifiable test errors. For teams that seek to keep things lean and efficient, this is a handy feature.
How does Trunk simplify the developer experience?
Trunk Flaky Tests offers an intuitive interface and real-time feedback, proactively flagging problem tests. This means developers are always in the loop and can promptly address issues. It takes the guesswork out of testing, ensuring projects are less about managing problems and more about creating solutions.
What is the process for quarantining flaky tests in Trunk?
In Trunk, quarantining flaky tests is made straightforward. Identified flaky tests can be isolated easily, ensuring they don't disrupt the CI pipeline. This feature acts as a safety net, allowing only reliable tests to influence build success. The process involves immediate isolation of flaky tests, providing time for developers to investigate without halting the workflow.
How does BuildPulse perform in real-world applications?
BuildPulse is effective in real-world applications by delivering essential analysis highlighting test reliability issues. It’s relied upon for its simplicity in identifying the problematic testing areas, which is crucial for smaller teams seeking to streamline efficiency without diving into more complex solutions.
Is Trunk ideal for large-scale enterprises?
Absolutely, Trunk is tailored for large-scale enterprises with complex CI/CD pipelines. Its holistic approach and advanced analytics provide the depth needed to handle challenging environments. For teams that need a multilayered tool to enhance productivity across diverse projects, Trunk makes an ideal partner.
Does BuildPulse integrate with GitHub?
Yes, BuildPulse integrates with GitHub to provide pull request comments and summarize flaky test analytics. It keeps developers informed about potential issues right there in the code review process, making it easier to maintain high code quality.
How does Trunk handle notifications for test failures?
Trunk offers real-time notifications across platforms, such as Slack and email, ensuring developers receive updates as they happen. This immediacy makes issues visible and actionable, reducing the downtime between detection and resolution.
What frameworks and CI providers are supported by Trunk?
Trunk is designed to be flexible, supporting a myriad of test frameworks and CI providers. This agnostic approach means it can fit into almost any development setup, making for an easy plug-and-play experience for diverse teams.
Why choose Trunk over other flaky test tools?
Trunk represents a more comprehensive solution, offering deep integration, advanced analytics, and automated workflow capabilities. It's particularly suitable for larger teams seeking to optimize not just flaky test management but the entire development lifecycle. With Trunk, you're not just addressing a problem; you're strengthening your entire development process.