Trunk vs TestRail
Trunk’s Flaky Tests is a comprehensive platform designed to detect, analyze, and manage flaky tests within your CI/CD pipeline.
Tired of clicking re-run? They were too.
Features
Notifications (GitHub, Slack, Email, etc.)
Test Framework and CI Provider Agnostic
Test Quarantining
Auto Detection
Comprehensive Dashboard
Integrated Ticketing
Detailed Failure Analysis
"Trunk's Flaky Test solution is so far the best one we've worked with, and we look forward to continuing to work with it."
"I primarily focused on the flaky tests tab and found all the information I sought. The app provided an excellent summary of our E2E pain points."
Security Overview
Your code is your IP, that’s why security and privacy are core to our design. We minimize data collection, storage, and access whenever possible. We operate using the principle of least privilege at all levels of our product and processes.
FAQs
How do you fix flaky tests?
Flaky tests can be a real headache, causing your CI/CD process to stumble over inconsistent results. To fix them, start by identifying the culprits. Trunk Flaky Tests offers detection features that can save you time here. Once identified, quarantine them to keep your main pipeline stable—a technique Trunk excels at. Then, dig into the root causes like asynchronous code, dependencies, or shared state issues. Refactor to eliminate these pitfalls, ensuring your tests are stable and isolated. And don't forget, continuous monitoring is the key to catching new flaky tests early.
How can you use TestRail to generate a flakiness report?
Generating a flakiness report in TestRail requires a bit of maneuvering, as it's not designed specifically for flaky test management. However, you can track test stability by analyzing historical test execution trends within its analytics features. Export the data and search for patterns or inconsistencies, which may hint at flaky behavior. For automated reporting, consider integrating TestRail with external tools or scripts that can crunch the numbers, letting you maintain an eye on flakiness without a manual deep dive each time.
Why are my tests flaky?
Flaky tests often crop up for reasons that can feel like a guessing game. Most causes boil down to variability in test environments. Think along the lines of asynchronous calls that finish at unpredictable times, shared state in the tests that muddles results, or external dependencies behaving erratically. Other sneaky culprits include race conditions and unreliable network calls. Understanding these usual suspects can help you pinpoint concerns efficiently and work toward stabilizing your tests.
What is an example of a flaky test?
Consider a unit test that verifies data retrieval from an external API—sometimes it passes, sometimes it doesn’t, due to network lag. Here’s another spot-on example: a UI test reliant on dynamic content loading speeds. If HTTP requests aren’t reliably completing before assertions check for responses, your test could sporadically fail. These instances underscore the essence of flaky tests: unreliable results without code changes, often requiring improved synchronization or retry strategies to iron out the wrinkles.
What features does TestRail offer to handle flaky tests?
TestRail shines as a comprehensive test management tool, though it wasn't built to specialize in flaky test issues directly. Its standout features—detailed reporting, test planning, and execution tracking—indirectly aid in identifying instability. Access to historical test data can help you spot patterns tied to flakiness. Integration capabilities with third-party tools can extend its coverage, but it lacks tailored capabilities for automatic flaky test isolation or real-time detection—which is where Trunk Flaky Tests takes the lead.
How does Trunk Flaky Tests detect flaky tests?
Trunk Flaky Tests harnesses advanced algorithms to pinpoint tests that show inconsistent results without requiring manual intervention. This automated detection is critical in streamlining your dev workflow, letting you address flakiness before it cascades into larger issues. By analyzing execution patterns and identifying anomalies, this tool saves your team from the manual drudgery of sifting through logs, helping maintain momentum in your CI/CD pipeline with an emphasis on reliability and confidence.
What is the benefit of quarantining flaky tests in Trunk?
Imagine sidelining a noisy player in a poker game until they quiet down—quarantining flaky tests does much the same for your workspace. Trunk’s quarantine feature temporarily isolates unreliable tests, ensuring they don’t hold up the show. This approach allows your team to push ahead with stable changes without distraction. By keeping flaky tests from blocking pivotal deployment stages, Trunk helps maintain a dynamic and reliable build environment, giving developers the freedom to focus on productive tasks.
How does Trunk Flaky Tests integrate with GitHub?
Trunk seamlessly integrates with GitHub, designed to harmonize with developers' needs. Imagine getting alerts and direct links to flaky tests right within your pull requests. This kind of synergy cuts down on context switching, allowing devs to stay focused and nimble. It strengthens your workflows and enhances visibility, ensuring that everyone on the team remains clued in and ready to act.
Can we integrate Jira with Trunk Flaky Tests for issue tracking?
Yes, Jira integration is baked into Trunk Flaky Tests, pairing issue tracking with flaky test management seamlessly. This integration provides transparency, enabling developers to prioritize and resolve issues promptly. By linking flaky test cases directly to corresponding Jira tickets, you minimize miscommunication, streamline your workflow, and ensure that tracking and resolving issues doesn’t become yet another time-consuming chore.
What communication tools are compatible with Trunk Flaky Tests?
Trunk Flaky Tests boasts a lineup of communicative compatibility that includes slack through webhooks, email notifications, and more. These pathways keep teams informed with real-time updates on test statuses and changes, minimizing downtime and amplifying team agility. This keeps everyone, from managers to developers, on the same page—even when working remotely or across different time zones.
When should I use TestRail instead of Trunk Flaky Tests?
If your organization requires comprehensive test case management—including planning, execution, and extensive reporting features—TestRail can be a solid choice. It's ideal for maintaining centralized oversight of test assets across multiple projects. But, if your team is wrestling with persistent flaky test problems or you need automated management of temperamental tests that slow down your CI/CD, Trunk Flaky Tests is the nimble solution that dives deep into the nuances of test flakiness.
How does pricing for Trunk Flaky Tests compare to TestRail?
Trunk Flaky Tests offers a welcoming variety of pricing options—free access for open source projects, for example—making it incredibly friendly to startups and small teams. TestRail’s pricing is more structured around enterprise management features, which might entail steeper commitments. As always, critically assess your team's goals and budget constraints to ensure you're investing in a toolset that fulfills your specific needs without breaking the bank.
What makes Trunk Flaky Tests developer-friendly?
Trunk is committed to creating tools that developers don’t just use but actually love. By offering comprehensive integration options—like GitHub issues—and embedding intuitive dashboards into daily workflows, Trunk Flaky Tests speaks the language of devs. It empowers them with features that are proactive rather than reactive, minimizing interruptions and providing actionable insights that enhance productivity and satisfaction.
What role does automation play in Trunk Flaky Tests?
Automation lies at the heart of Trunk Flaky Tests, turning what traditionally might have been tedious troubleshooting into a seamless experience. It eliminates trial and error with its automated detection, ensuring flaky tests are spotted and managed without human intervention. This frees developers to focus on what truly counts—building innovative solutions—while reducing the cognitive load of hunting down unpredictable, rogue tests in the wild.
What is SOC 2 Type 2 compliance and how is it relevant?
SOC 2 Type 2 compliance is a benchmark for security and data protection standards critical in our anytime-anywhere connected world. Trunk Flaky Tests being compliant underscores its commitment to safeguarding user data while providing powerful but secure tools. In today’s evolving tech landscape, choosing a SOC 2 Type 2-compliant solution like Trunk ensures you can focus on expanding your software capabilities and reassure your data integrity hasn't been compromised.
