Strategies to Prevent Flaky Tests
Flaky tests can frustrate developers and slow down your progress. You can prevent flaky tests with some proven strategies. Here’s how you can make your tests more reliable:
Avoid Asynchronous Waits
Using asynchronous waits can make your tests inconsistent. Instead of relying on timeouts and delays, switch to explicit waits. For example, if you are testing a web application, use WebDriver's ExpectedConditions to wait for an element to be clickable. This ensures the test waits for a specific condition rather than a fixed amount of time. By doing this, your tests become more predictable and less prone to fail due to timing issues.
Mock External Dependencies
External systems like databases or APIs can cause test flakiness. You can avoid this by mocking these dependencies. Libraries such as Mockito for Java or sinon.js for JavaScript allow you to create mock objects that simulate the behavior of real objects. This way, your tests run in isolation and are not affected by external factors like network latency or server downtime. For example, use a mock API server to simulate API responses instead of making actual network requests.
Stable Test Environments
Inconsistent test environments can lead to flaky tests. Ensure your test environment is stable and mirrors the production environment as closely as possible. Use tools like Docker to create consistent environments. Docker containers can standardize your environment across different machines, reducing the chance of environment-specific issues.
Use the same versions of libraries and tools across environments.
Regularly update and maintain your test environment.
Minimize Test Order Dependency
Design your tests to be independent of each other. Tests that rely on the outcome of previous tests can become flaky. Each test should set up its data and environment, ensuring it can run in any order. For example, if you are testing a shopping cart feature, each test should create a new cart rather than relying on a cart created by another test.
Use setup and teardown methods to prepare and clean up the test environment.
Avoid shared states between tests.
By following these strategies, you can significantly reduce the likelihood of flaky tests. Focus on making your tests predictable, isolated, and independent.
Best Practices for Writing Reliable Tests
Writing reliable tests is essential to maintaining a healthy codebase. Here are best practices to help you achieve this:
Proper Synchronization
Synchronization ensures that all asynchronous operations are completed before you make assertions in your tests. For instance, in JavaScript, use async and await to manage asynchronous calls. If you are testing an API call, await its response before checking the results. This practice reduces the risk of your tests failing due to incomplete operations.
Use Promise.all to handle multiple asynchronous operations.
Employ test frameworks like Jest or Mocha that support asynchronous testing.
Stable Locators
In UI tests, using stable locators helps avoid errors like "element not found." Instead of relying on dynamic IDs, opt for more stable selectors like class names or data attributes. For example, in a React application, use data-testid attributes to select elements. This makes your tests more resilient to changes in the HTML structure.
Avoid using XPath selectors, as they can be brittle.
Prefer CSS selectors that are less likely to change.
Clean Test Data
Using consistent and reliable test data is crucial. If your tests rely on external databases, ensure the data remains unchanged. You can achieve this by using fixtures or mock data. For example, if you are testing a user login feature, use a predefined set of usernames and passwords. This helps maintain consistency across different test runs.
Use fixtures to set up test data before running tests.
Clean up test data after each test to prevent state pollution.
Isolation
Each test should run in isolation to ensure it does not affect others. This means setting up and tearing down the environment for each test. For instance, if you are testing a user registration feature, ensure that each test starts with a clean state. This prevents previous tests from impacting the current test.
Utilize setup and teardown hooks provided by test frameworks like JUnit for Java or pytest for Python.
Avoid global states that can bleed into other tests.
By following these best practices, you can make your tests more reliable and easier to maintain. Proper synchronization, stable locators, clean test data, and test isolation are key components in achieving dependable tests.
Monitoring and Maintenance
Maintaining the reliability of your tests requires ongoing effort. Here are some strategies to help you monitor and maintain your tests effectively:
Regular Review
Regularly reviewing your test results can help you identify flaky tests. Flaky tests are those that sometimes pass and sometimes fail without any changes in the code. By examining test logs and results, you can spot patterns or inconsistencies. Schedule periodic reviews—weekly or bi-weekly—to catch flakiness early. This proactive approach allows you to address issues before they become problematic.
Check for tests that fail intermittently.
Look for patterns in test failures to identify root causes.
Continuous Integration
Integrating your tests into Continuous Integration (CI) pipelines ensures continuous feedback on the health of your codebase. Tools like Jenkins, CircleCI, and Travis CI can automatically run your tests every time you commit code. This integration helps catch flaky tests early and provides immediate feedback to developers.
Set up automated test runs for every code commit.
Use CI dashboards to monitor test results in real-time.
Feedback Loops
Encourage developers to report and fix flaky tests as soon as they encounter them. Establish a culture where identifying and resolving flaky tests is a priority. Quick feedback loops ensure that issues are addressed promptly, preventing them from affecting other parts of the codebase.
Create a system for developers to report flaky tests.
Prioritize fixing flaky tests in your development workflow.
Tooling
Employing the right tools can make tracking and addressing flaky tests easier. Test management tools like TestRail, Zephyr, and Xray offer features to monitor test performance and flakiness. These tools can help you keep track of test results, identify flaky tests, and manage your test suite more efficiently.
Use test management tools to organize and monitor your tests.
Leverage analytics features to gain insights into test performance.
By implementing regular reviews, integrating tests into CI pipelines, establishing feedback loops, and using the right tools, you can effectively monitor and maintain your tests. This approach helps ensure that your tests remain reliable and reduces the impact of flaky tests on your development process.
Taking Control of Testing
Taking control of flaky tests starts with reliable detection and prevention. Trunk is building a tool to conquer flaky tests once and for all. You’ll get all of the features of the big guy's internal systems without the headache of managing it. With Trunk Flaky Tests, you’ll be able to:
Autodetect the flaky tests in your build system
See them in a dashboard across all your repos
Quarantine tests with one click or automatically
Get detailed stats to target the root cause of the problem
Get reports weekly, nightly, or instantly sent right to email and Slack
Intelligently file tickets to the right engineer
If you’re interested in getting beta access, sign up here.
