In software development, managing code changes can get tricky. Merge queues help with this process. They organize and streamline merging code changes into the main project. Here’s what you need to know about them.
What Are Merge Queues?
Definition and Purpose of Merge Queues
A merge queue is a tool that automates the merging of pull requests into a main branch. Its main purpose: ensure the main branch stays stable and passes all tests. Merge queues help avoid breaking changes that could disrupt the entire project.
How Merge Queues Manage Pull Request Order
Merge queues use a first-in-first-out (FIFO) system to manage pull requests. Here's how it works:
Queueing: When you add a pull request, the merge queue places it in line.
Temporary Branches: The queue creates temporary branches to test changes.
Validation: It checks if the pull request can merge without conflicts.
Merging: If all checks pass, the request merges into the main branch.
Benefits of Using Merge Queues
Using merge queues offers several advantages:
Streamlined Development: Automates the merging process, saving time.
Reduced Conflicts: Ensures all code changes are compatible before merging.
Consistency: Keeps the main branch stable and functional.
Comparison to Traditional Merging Methods
Traditional merging methods often involve manually updating branches and running tests. This can lead to:
More Conflicts: Manual merges may not catch all issues.
Time-Consuming: Developers spend extra time resolving conflicts.
Instability: Main branch might break if incompatible changes merge.
In contrast, merge queues automate these tasks, offering a more efficient and reliable solution.
How Merge Queues Work
Key Mechanisms of Merge Queues
Merge queues operate using several key mechanisms. These mechanisms ensure that code merges smoothly and without issues.
1. First-in-First-out Order Maintaining: Merge queues follow a first-in-first-out (FIFO) system. This means that the first pull request added to the queue will be the first one processed. This order helps keep the process fair and organized.
2. Creation of Temporary Branches for Validation: When you add a pull request to the merge queue, it creates a temporary branch. This branch includes the changes from the pull request and the latest version of the main branch. The queue uses this branch to run tests and checks, ensuring that the new code doesn't break anything.
3. Grouping of Pull Requests with Merge_group: Sometimes, the merge queue groups multiple pull requests together using a feature called merge_group. This means it tests several pull requests at once to see if they can all merge without issues. If they pass the tests, the merge queue merges them into the main branch as a group.
4. Ensuring Required Checks Are Satisfied Before Merging: Before merging any pull request, the merge queue ensures that all required checks are satisfied. These checks might include automated tests, code reviews, or other validation steps. If any check fails, the pull request won't merge, and the queue will notify the developer to fix the issues.
Key Takeaways:
FIFO System: Keeps the merge process organized.
Temporary Branches: Used for testing changes safely.
Merge_group: Allows grouping and testing of multiple pull requests.
Required Checks: Ensures stable and functional code merges.
These mechanisms work together to maintain a smooth and efficient merging process, reducing the chances of conflicts and keeping the main branch stable.
Managing and Optimizing Merge Queues
To make the most of merge queues, you need to manage and optimize them effectively. This involves several steps and options that ensure your pull requests merge smoothly and efficiently.
Adding Pull Requests to the Merge Queue
1. How to Add a Pull Request: To add a pull request to the merge queue, someone with write access to the repository clicks the "Add to merge queue" button. This action places the pull request in line, following the FIFO system. The queue then starts the process of creating a temporary branch and running the necessary checks.
Handling Successful and Failing CI Checks
2. Successful CI Checks: When a pull request passes all required CI checks, the merge queue moves it forward. The changes from the pull request then merge into the main branch. This ensures that only code that has passed all tests gets merged, keeping the main branch stable.
3. Failing CI Checks: If a pull request fails any required checks, the merge queue removes it from the line. The developer receives a notification explaining the issues. They must then fix the code and re-add the pull request to the queue. This process ensures that only reliable and tested code makes it to the main branch.
Options for Jumping to the Top of the Queue
4. Jumping to the Top: Sometimes, you might need a pull request to merge quickly. In such cases, you can use the option to jump to the top of the queue. However, be cautious with this feature. Jumping to the top causes all in-progress pull requests to rebuild, potentially slowing down the entire process.
Configuring 'Only Merge Non-Failing Pull Requests' Setting
5. Non-Failing Pull Requests: The "Only merge non-failing pull requests" setting is crucial for maintaining code quality. When enabled, it ensures that only pull requests passing all required checks get merged. If disabled, even pull requests with failing checks can merge, as long as the last one in the group passes. This setting helps manage intermittent test failures but should be used carefully.
Key Takeaways:
Add to Merge Queue: Simplifies the process of managing pull requests.
Handle CI Checks: Ensures only tested and stable code merges.
Jump to Top Option: Offers quick merges but use sparingly.
Non-Failing Setting: Maintains high code quality standards.
By managing and optimizing merge queues effectively, you can streamline your development process, reduce conflicts, and maintain a stable main branch.
Troubleshooting Merge Queue Issues
Managing merge queues isn't always smooth sailing. Sometimes, issues arise that need quick resolution to keep your workflow efficient. Let’s dive into some common problems and their solutions.
Common Reasons for Pull Request Removal from the Queue
1. Failing Required Checks: A pull request might fail required status checks. This failure removes it from the merge queue. Reasons include failing tests or conflicts with the base branch. When this happens, developers must fix the issues and re-add the pull request.
2. Timeout: Merge queues have a set timeout for how long they wait for CI results. If the results don't come in time, the system assumes failure and removes the pull request.
3. Manual Removal: Sometimes, a user might manually remove a pull request from the queue. This can happen due to changes in project priorities or recognizing issues that need addressing outside of the queue.
4. Branch Protection Failures: If the merge queue encounters branch protection rule conflicts, it removes the pull request. These rules ensure that all changes meet certain criteria before merging.
Handling Intermittent Test Failures
Intermittent test failures can be frustrating. They cause false negatives that remove pull requests unnecessarily. Here’s how to handle them:
1. Investigate and Stabilize Tests: Identify flaky tests by running them multiple times. Stabilize these tests to reduce false negatives.
2. Use the 'Only Merge Non-Failing Pull Requests' Setting: Disabling this setting allows merging of pull requests even if some tests fail, provided the last one in the group passes. This helps manage intermittent failures without blocking the queue.
3. Retry Mechanism: Implement a retry mechanism for failed tests. This can automatically rerun tests a few times before declaring a failure.
Adjusting CI Configuration for Merge Queues
Proper CI configuration is essential for smooth merge queue operation. Here are some adjustments you might need:
1. Triggering Checks: Ensure your CI system triggers checks for merge_group events. This ensures that every pull request in the queue gets validated with the latest code changes.
2. Updating Workflows: Update your CI workflows to include merge_group events as triggers. This involves modifying your CI configuration files to listen for these events, ensuring checks run when needed.
3. Build Concurrency: Adjust the build concurrency setting to control how many merge_group webhooks dispatch simultaneously. This helps manage the load on your CI system and speeds up the process.
Monitoring and Resolving Branch Protection Failures
Branch protection rules are vital for maintaining code quality. However, they can sometimes cause issues in the merge queue. Here’s how to monitor and resolve them:
1. Regular Monitoring: Keep an eye on the branch protection status. Use tools or scripts to alert you when there are issues.
2. Resolve Conflicts: When a branch protection rule fails, investigate the cause. It could be due to failing tests, outdated code, or conflicts. Resolve these issues promptly to maintain queue efficiency.
3. Communication: Maintain open communication with your team about branch protection rules. Ensure everyone knows the requirements and how to address failures.
Key Takeaways:
Common Issues: Understand why pull requests get removed.
Intermittent Tests: Implement strategies to handle flaky tests.
CI Configuration: Properly configure your CI for merge queues.
Branch Protection: Monitor and resolve protection rule failures.
By addressing these troubleshooting steps, you can maintain an efficient and reliable merge queue, reducing downtime and keeping your development process on track.
Best Practices for Using Merge Queues
Using merge queues effectively ensures a smooth and efficient development process. Here are some best practices to follow:
Ensuring All Required Checks Are Defined and Up-to-Date
1. Define Comprehensive Checks: List all necessary checks that each pull request must pass. These might include unit tests, integration tests, and linting checks. Ensure these checks cover all critical aspects of your codebase.
2. Regular Updates: Periodically review and update these checks. As your codebase evolves, new checks might become necessary, and old ones might need adjustments. This ensures that your checks remain relevant and effective.
3. Automate Updating Checks: Use scripts or CI tools to automate the updating process. This helps in keeping checks consistent across various branches and pull requests.
4. Documentation: Maintain clear documentation of all required checks. This helps team members understand what is expected and reduces misunderstandings.
Regularly Reviewing and Adjusting Merge Queue Settings
1. Schedule Reviews: Set regular intervals for reviewing merge queue settings. This could be weekly or monthly, depending on the activity of your repository.
2. Analyze Performance: Look at the performance and efficiency of your merge queue. Are there frequent bottlenecks or delays? Use this data to make informed adjustments.
3. Adjust Settings: Modify settings such as build concurrency, merge methods (merge, rebase, squash), and status check timeouts based on your analysis. This helps in optimizing the merge queue for your team’s needs.
4. Feedback Loop: Create a feedback loop with your team. Encourage them to report issues and suggest improvements. This collaborative approach ensures that the merge queue settings evolve with the team's requirements.
Collaborating with Team Members to Manage the Queue Efficiently
1. Open Communication Channels: Use tools like Slack or Microsoft Teams to keep communication lines open. Discuss the status of the merge queue regularly in stand-up meetings or dedicated channels.
2. Assign Roles: Designate roles for managing the merge queue. This could include a merge queue manager who oversees the process and resolves issues promptly.
3. Training and Onboarding: Provide training sessions for new team members on using the merge queue. Ensure they understand the best practices and the importance of following the queue’s rules.
4. Collaborative Problem Solving: When issues arise, collaborate to solve them. This might involve pair programming, code reviews, or brainstorming sessions to address conflicts or test failures.
Using Status Check Timeouts to Avoid Long Wait Times
1. Set Reasonable Timeouts: Define timeouts for status checks to prevent them from running indefinitely. This ensures that the merge queue progresses smoothly without getting stuck.
2. Monitor Timeout Efficiency: Regularly monitor the effectiveness of your timeout settings. Adjust them if builds often time out before completing or if there are frequent delays in the queue.
3. Notify Developers: Automatically notify developers when their pull requests time out. This enables them to investigate and resolve the issue quickly, minimizing delays.
4. Balance Speed and Thoroughness: Find a balance between the speed of merging and the thoroughness of checks. While it's important to avoid long wait times, ensure that the checks are still comprehensive enough to maintain code quality.
Key Takeaways:
Define Checks: Ensure all required checks are comprehensive and up-to-date.
Regular Reviews: Periodically review and adjust merge queue settings.
Team Collaboration: Collaborate with team members for efficient queue management.
Timeout Settings: Use status check timeouts to avoid long wait times.
Implementing these best practices helps maintain an efficient merge queue, ensuring a smooth and reliable development process.
Take Control of Your Merge Process
Trunk has built a better way to manage your merge process, eliminating long wait times and reducing CI costs. With Trunk Merge Queue, you’ll be able to:
Autotest your PRs against the latest commit on your main branch
Dynamically create parallel queues for faster merges
Merge PRs automatically once all requirements are met
View detailed stats and performance metrics for your CI pipelines
Seamlessly integrate with your existing CI/CD workflows
If you’re ready to streamline your PR process and speed up your development, try it out for free.
